Kingston’s proposed new dockless e-bike scheme may support greener travel, but weak controls risk more pavement obstruction, especially for older and disabled pedestrians.

A Kingston Society Soapbox article by Tony Lancaster* (all photographs taken by me around my local streets)


E-bikes in Kingston

Greener travel must not mean surrendered pavements

Kingston Council is being asked to approve new concession contracts for dockless e-bike hire services across Kingston and Sutton. The report to Place Committee on 4 June 2026 recommends awarding two separate contracts, each for three years from September 2026, with a possible two-year extension.

The case for e-bikes is not difficult to understand. They can help people make short journeys without a car. They can connect neighbourhoods to stations, town centres, workplaces and schools. They can make cycling possible for people who might not otherwise manage hills, distance or effort. In principle, they belong within any serious attempt to reduce car dependence.

But the question is not whether e-bikes can be useful. The question is whether a dockless e-bike scheme can be made compatible with a safe, accessible and well-managed public realm.

The growing problem of pavement obstruction

Kingston residents do not need a policy paper to tell them there is a problem. They can see it on the street. E-bikes are frequently left across pavements, near crossings, in front of entrances, beside bus stops, on narrow pedestrian routes and in places where they create real obstruction. For some people this is merely irritating. For others it is dangerous. A badly abandoned e-bike can be a serious hazard for a visually impaired person, a wheelchair user, a mobility scooter user, a parent with a buggy, or an older pedestrian walking with care.

The Council’s report recognises this, but too lightly. It refers to ‘inconsiderate parking’, ‘nuisance’ and obstruction. It says bidders were assessed on managing risky behaviour, managing inconsiderate parking and identifying parking locations. Under equalities implications, it accepts that the main potential negative impact is the obstruction caused by inconsiderately parked e-bikes, especially for visually impaired people and wheelchair or mobility scooter users. That acknowledgement is welcome, but acknowledgement is not management.

What is missing from the public report is the hard operational detail. How quickly must an obstructing bike be removed? What exactly counts as obstruction? What penalties apply to operators? Are those penalties large enough to change behaviour? What happens after repeated failure? Can fleet numbers be reduced? Will performance data be published? Will residents have a simple reporting route? Will parking bays be installed before fleet numbers increase, or only after the problem becomes worse? These are not minor administrative questions. They go to the heart of the scheme.

The proposed expansion is significant. The report indicates that the new contract could result in 400 to 500 active e-bikes per borough from the start, compared with a previous fleet of about 220. That is a major increase in the number of commercial vehicles occupying public space. If parking controls are not visible, enforceable and immediate, the nuisance will grow with the fleet.

❝


Dockless e-bikes have the potential to be a major positive step forwards for London, but to work for our city they need to work for all Londoners.

Cllr Kieron Williams of London Councils

❞

Revenue, expansion and the dockless model

There is also a financial dimension. The Council report is explicit that the two councils want to move to a revenue-generating contract. The arrangement would require no funding from Kingston or Sutton, with costs borne by the operators. It would also generate income for the boroughs. The report estimates about £55,000 income per borough in the first year, rising to about £90,000 per borough per year if coverage and fleet size doubles. The total concession value across both operators and both boroughs is put at £7.88 million over five years.

It would be unfair to say that revenue alone is driving the decision. The environmental and transport arguments are real. But it is entirely reasonable to ask whether the financial attractiveness of the scheme is encouraging the Council to understate its public-realm costs. A scheme that costs the Council nothing, delivers a green transport headline and brings in revenue will always look tempting. The danger is that the convenience of the contract is allowed to outrun the discipline required on the street. This also raises a larger question. Why has dockless become the default?

London already has a long-established docking model in the Santander Cycles scheme, still widely known as ‘Boris bikes’. That model has an obvious civic virtue: the bicycle has a proper home. It is hired from a docking station and returned to a docking station. The system is not perfect. Docking stations are expensive, they take up space, they are not always where a rider wants them, and they can be full or empty at the wrong time. But they do one thing very well. They make the storage of the bike part of the infrastructure, not an afterthought left to user behaviour.

Dockless schemes reverse that logic. They are cheaper and faster to deploy because they do not require a full network of physical docking stations. They are attractive to operators because they can scale quickly. They are attractive to users because a journey can often end closer to the destination. They are attractive to councils because the public authority does not have to fund or build the whole system in advance.

But this is precisely the problem. The dockless model shifts the burden from designed infrastructure to behavioural enforcement. Instead of a bike having a fixed place to go, the system relies on apps, GPS, user instructions, penalties, operator patrols, reporting systems and geofenced parking areas. In other words, it replaces a simple physical solution with a complicated management problem.

Lessons from London and beyond

Other parts of London have recognised this more clearly. TfL has warned that badly parked dockless e-bikes create significant safety problems, especially for disabled and older people, and is moving towards designated parking on red routes. Westminster has introduced a large network of parking bays. The City of London requires dockless bikes to be parked in designated areas and sets expectations for removal of obstructing bikes. London Councils has publicly complained that some e-bike operators have failed to respect local agreements, leaving bikes strewn across pavements.

The direction of travel is clear. London is not simply embracing dockless freedom. It is trying, rather belatedly, to retrofit discipline onto a system that was allowed to expand faster than its civic rules.

European cities offer a further lesson, though I am not claiming an exact comparison. They have trialled E-scooters which raise different legal, safety and riding issues but similar parking problems. The experience from Europe suggests a clear pattern: where shared micro-mobility schemes become associated with widespread pavement clutter, poor parking and a perception of disorder, public support can evaporate and operators can find themselves forced out. Paris withdrew shared rental e-scooters following a public vote in which residents backed a ban. Madrid moved to cancel rental e-scooter licences after operators failed to control parking and circulation. Prague is banning shared e-scooters from 2026, while making a distinction between scooters and shared bikes. The lesson is not that e-bikes and e-scooters are the same, but that persistent parking abuse and street clutter can ultimately provoke a public backlash that ends with schemes being withdrawn.

The point is not that Kingston should ban e-bikes. It is that residents and councils alike become frustrated when pavements and public spaces end up functioning as parking areas for commercial hire schemes.

Kingston Society supports greener movement, active travel and reduced dependence on cars. But active travel must not be used as an excuse for badly managed streets. Pavements are not spare commercial storage space. They are the most basic part of the civic realm. They must remain safe, dignified and accessible for everyone.

The Council should therefore make approval of the new contracts conditional on much clearer safeguards. These should include mandatory parking zones in busy areas, prompt removal of obstructing bikes, meaningful penalties for operators, transparent performance monitoring, limits on fleet expansion until parking infrastructure is in place, and a simple public reporting system.

Dockless e-bikes may have a useful role in Kingston’s transport future. But if they are to be part of a civilised town, they must be governed as part of the town, not merely scattered across it.

The issue is not whether e-bikes can contribute to greener travel. They can and do. The issue is whether Kingston has put in place the safeguards needed to ensure that the benefits are not outweighed by the impact on pedestrians and the wider public realm. The Council’s report is detailed when it comes to the financial case for the scheme, but much less clear about how problems such as pavement obstruction will be prevented and enforced against. That should give councillors pause before they sign off the contracts.

*the views expressed here are not necessarily the views of The Kingston Society.

Share this story, choose your platform!

Last Updated on June 4, 2026 by Kingston Society