London’s housing debate shifts towards form, scale and public consent

A Kingston Society Soapbox article by Tony Lancaster*


Two recent London Assembly Planning and Regeneration Committee documents suggest a subtle but important shift in the capital’s housing debate. The first, Between skyscrapers and semis: London’s missing mid-rise housing, argues that London should make far more use of mid-rise development, broadly understood as the zone between suburban low-rise and tower-led growth. The second, a letter from the Committee chair to the Mayor titled Better Design for London, focuses more squarely on the quality of design, the gap between professional and public preferences, and the need for more meaningful community engagement in shaping growth. Taken together, the documents amount to a call for a different kind of densification – one less dependent on very tall buildings, more attentive to context, and more alert to the politics of consent.

The false choice between towers and sprawl

The mid-rise report begins from a simple proposition. London is not especially dense by the standards of comparable world cities, and it remains characterised by a very high proportion of low-rise housing. In that context, the Committee argues that the city has tended to frame the housing question too crudely, as a choice between building upwards in tall buildings or expanding outwards. Its answer is that there is another model available. Mid-rise development, especially in well-connected locations, is presented as a way of achieving higher densities while remaining closer to the grain and scale of much of the European city. It is described not as an exotic import but as a familiar and workable urban form that can support shops, schools, transport, family life and neighbourliness.

This is not merely a matter of taste. The report suggests that mid-rise development may offer a more politically durable form of growth because it is easier for many Londoners to accept than either towers or suburban sprawl. The Committee cites polling indicating stronger support for low-rise and mid-rise homes than for high-rise development, while also noting that Londoners care not only about the number of homes built but also about safety, transport access, green space and design quality. The implication is that public support for housebuilding is conditional rather than absolute. People may accept more homes if those homes are delivered in forms they recognise as liveable and well integrated into their surroundings.

❝

Mid-rise should become the default answer to housing development in London

❞

Why mid-rise is being recast as London’s missing middle

From that point, the report moves into policy. It argues that the current London Plan does not give enough clarity or force to mid-rise development. It recommends that the next London Plan should establish mid-rise as the preferred form of new residential development in high-access locations, define it explicitly, and revisit the idea of a density matrix to guide where different forms of intensification are appropriate. The Committee is careful not to suggest a universal height cap. It accepts that some of the best-connected locations may justify greater height. But its overall position is that policy should stop treating towers as the implicit default for urban intensification and instead place greater emphasis on the relationship between density, transport accessibility, site context and urban form.

❝

Effective community engagement, early-stage and ongoing throughout the process, is critical to successful design and support for development

❞

Design, consent and the limits of expert taste

The Better Design for London letter overlaps with this argument, but from another angle. Where the report is concerned with typology and density, the letter is concerned with what Londoners actually want buildings to look and feel like. It points to evidence heard by the Committee suggesting that there is often a disconnect between public preferences and what the development sector, and sometimes the architectural profession, tends to produce. It highlights recurring public preference for coherent frontages, human-scaled heights, contextual materials and buildings that fit with local character. It does not argue that only traditional architecture should be permitted. Rather, it suggests that traditional forms often embody qualities people respond to positively, and that contemporary architecture could equally succeed if it took those preferences more seriously.

This is an important distinction. The letter is not crudely nostalgic. It does not simply oppose modern architecture or ask for stylistic pastiche. Instead, it argues for what might be called evidence-based design. In other words, if there is robust evidence that certain forms, materials and street patterns command broad public support, then planning policy should take that evidence seriously rather than treating it as somehow secondary to expert judgement. The Committee therefore recommends updating Housing Design Standards to better reflect these findings, promoting design codes developed with local communities, encouraging neighbourhood plans, and drawing more systematically on post-occupancy evidence, citizen science and structured public engagement.

❝

The public did not seem to agree with the award-winning buildings

❞

Growth, trust and the politics of legitimacy

At the heart of both documents lies the same deeper concern, which is trust. The mid-rise report notes that only a small minority of Londoners currently engage in the planning process and that many do not know how to do so. The design letter argues that there is appetite to participate in placemaking, but that this appetite is not being properly met. Both documents therefore suggest that London’s planning difficulty is not simply a shortage of homes or a shortage of land. It is also a deficit of confidence. Many people feel that change happens to them, not with them. If so, then opposition to development cannot be understood merely as nimbyism or irrational resistance. It may also reflect a system that has too often offered consultation late, narrowly, or in forms that leave little visible trace on outcomes.

That point matters in outer London as much as inner London, and perhaps more. The mid-rise report sees substantial potential for intensification around suburban stations and in accessible town centres, but it also recognises the political difficulty of making such change acceptable. Its discussion of Croydon’s design code experiment is telling. The Committee appears to accept that design codes can provide certainty and unlock housing delivery, but it also notes that certainty alone is not enough. Without quality safeguards and local legitimacy, such policies risk provoking exactly the sort of backlash that leads them to be reversed. In that sense, both documents are making a similar argument. Growth may need to be faster and more substantial, but it must also be better shaped, better explained and better grounded in local character and public understanding.

For groups such as the Kingston Society, there is something both encouraging and cautionary here. Encouraging, because these documents recognise that design, scale, typology and civic participation are not cosmetic extras added after the serious business of housing numbers. They are central to whether growth works, socially and politically. Cautionary, because the Assembly’s position still sits within a strong growth agenda. The objective remains a large increase in housing delivery. The argument is not for less development, but for development that is more acceptable, more humane in scale, and more likely to command durable support.

In that sense, the two documents may mark a useful change in tone at London-wide level. They suggest that the old binaries – tall versus low, growth versus resistance, expert judgement versus public opinion – are no longer quite good enough. What is emerging instead is a more layered conversation about the kind of city London wants to become, and about how design, density and democracy might be brought back into better alignment.

*the views expressed here are not necessarily the views of The Kingston Society.

Share this story, choose your platform!