Matchstick towns and cardboard codes: the flimsy fantasy of Britain’s planning system and Design Codes

A Kingston Society Soapbox article by Tony Lancaster*


The architecture of indifference: Why our towns feel like nowhere at all

When was the last time you walked through Kingston, or any town, and looking around felt anything but quiet dismay, or a mordant ennui? Not just at the glass-and-steel monstrosities looming over their older and wiser neighbours, but at the everyday buildings—the ones that once formed the fabric of community. The high street is a parade of homogenised shopfronts, or, just as likely, empty units dressed with half-hearted vinyl decals to mask the decay. The pubs that once anchored neighbourhoods are either soulless chains or shuttered ghosts, waiting to be flattened for another block of meanly proportioned, buy-to-let hutches. The new ‘mixed-use’ developments are neither mixed nor used, their dead-eyed retail spaces gathering dust while the flats above, crammed and joyless, are sold off-plan to investors who will never set foot in them. What’s left of organically evolved townscapes cower behind grey cladding and ‘value-engineered’ façades, neither welcoming nor imposing, just blankly indifferent.

Instead of human-centred urbanism, we got a wasteland of throwaway buildings—nothing built to last, nothing built to love, just a creeping, joyless erosion of place until nowhere feels like anywhere at all, and anywhere is nowhere you’d want to be.

From market town to monoculture: Kingston’s battle against placelessness

Kingston, like so many towns, suffers from the gradual, insidious erosion of place; the slow accumulation of decisions made with indifference, or worse, with that peculiar brand of bureaucratic pragmatism that drains a place of its vitality. A street that once had an interesting mishmash of buildings and local shops now hosts a lifeless parade of anonymous façades, their signage the only distinguishing feature. A new development arrives, promising a “vibrant community” and “iconic architecture,” and a “gateway” (to what?) but delivers an awkward pastiche of glass-and-cladding structures, their thin gestures towards historic building—a few token bricks roughly the colour of the Town Hall—feeling more like a gesture architecture than intelligent design.

And yet, this dismay isn’t universal or inevitable . There are moments—small, fleeting moments—when a place still surprises you. A street corner where the sun hits an old building just right, revealing textures you’d never noticed. A scrap of green where you least expect it, defiantly pushing up through the concrete. A tiny independent café stubbornly holding its ground, resisting the tide of homogeneity. But these moments feel like accidents rather than intentions.

Kingston, like many places, has been built up and hollowed out in cycles. It was once a place of market-town vibrancy, then a mid-century car-centric experiment in urban modernism (some of it commendable, some of it regrettable), then a 1990s retail hub, and now it stands at a critical crossroads. It could become another indistinct, investor-driven patchwork, where tiny private spaces masquerade as benevolently gifted public realm. Or it could rediscover itself—not through nostalgia, but through a meaningful reconnection with its own identity.

What are design codes? Selling the vision for better places

Imagine a system that guarantees communities get the towns they deserve—places where new development is empathetic to local character, where design is led by quality rather than a race to the bottom. This is the promise of design codes.

Design codes set clear, prescriptive rules for development. They regulate elements such as building heights, street layouts, materials, and architectural styles, ensuring consistency. Their purpose is to provide certainty, particularly in large projects involving multiple stakeholders, by removing ambiguity from the planning process.

When done properly, design codes make planning predictable, community-led, and focused on enhancing local character rather than serving developer convenience. But they are only as strong as their enforcement. In Britain, that enforcement is patchy at best, routinely overridden by developer objections and local authorities too weak or underfunded to resist.

Successful design codes exist—Poundbury is often cited as an exemplar, with its strict adherence to a traditional architectural aesthetic and mixed-use planning principles. Yet, while some praise its coherence and human-scale design, others criticise it as a contrived, overly nostalgic pastiche that enforces an idealised version of the past rather than fostering genuine, contemporary place-making. The lesson from Poundbury is that rigid codes can achieve consistency, but whether that consistency produces authentic, thriving communities or stylised artifice is still up for debate. Where design codes are weakly applied, they become a fig leaf for bad development.

❝

…if you want design codes to work, don’t have a planning system like the UK’s…
— Rob Cowan : Urbanist, author, cartoonist, researcher and consultant. Design Codes: An International Comparison. An Urban Design Group Presentation (LINK).

❞

The fight for design codes

Design codes are one of the few planning reforms that hold promise, offering clear, enforceable rules to shape better places. They were meant to replace the vague, easily overridden design policies that allow Britain to churn out bland, poorly designed estates. But, like so many planning reforms before them, they were sabotaged by underfunding, political inertia, and a planning system that developers manipulate at will.

The National Model Design Code (NMDC) was meant to bring clarity. Instead, its implementation has been half-hearted at best. Local authorities lack expertise and resources, developers exploit loopholes, and community engagement has been a rushed, tick-box exercise. Without proper funding, training, and legal backing, design codes risk becoming another casualty in Britain’s long history of abandoned planning ideas.

The 2022 NMDC Monitoring and Evaluation Final Report, led by University College London (UCL) and published by the UK Government, confirmed what many already suspected: good intentions, woeful execution. Councils were expected to deliver but were given only £50,000 each to develop codes—an amount laughably inadequate for the scale of work required. The result? Design codes that varied wildly in quality, communities barely consulted, and enforcement that was little more than a suggestion.

A new era for design? Labour’s opportunity to build better places

When the history of the Conservative government’s planning strategy is written, design codes may stand as one of its few achievements. While much of the planning system has been paralysed by infighting and policy reversals, the move towards clear, enforceable design guidance offered a rare moment of coherence.

But now Labour must decide what comes next. Will design codes be cast aside in the rush to deliver 1.5 million homes, or will Labour recognise that good design is not a luxury but an economic and social necessity? Angela Rayner and Matthew Pennycook have gestured towards “high-quality, well-designed and sustainable” housing, but gestures are not policy.

There is an opportunity here. Labour could refine the design agenda—not by scrapping the work done, but by simplifying codes, ensuring they support rather than hinder much-needed housing. The evidence is clear: poorer communities suffer from worse design, and Labour must treat this as a fundamental issue of inequality. Get this right, and design codes could be the foundation of a more ambitious planning vision—one that builds not just houses but better places.

Conclusion: design codes or design chaos?

Britain faces a choice: build quickly and regret it, or build well and benefit for generations. Design codes are not just about aesthetics—they are about economic stability, social well-being, and the fundamental right of communities to shape their own surroundings.
Labour must:
1.
Give design codes legal weight so developers cannot ignore them.
2. Provide permanent funding for local authorities to develop and enforce them.
3. Train in-house urban designers rather than relying on private consultants.
4. Make community engagement meaningful rather than a rushed formality.
The next five years will determine whether design codes become a footnote in planning history or a genuine tool for building better places. Britain has wasted too many opportunities. This cannot be another one.

*the views expressed here are not necessarily the views of The Kingston Society.

Share this story, choose your platform!

Last Updated on February 11, 2025 by Kingston Society