Planning application summary 26/00295/FUL – 163 Kingston Road, New Malden KT3 3NN 


Design quality remains the central question

Summary

A planning application has been submitted for 163 Kingston Road, New Malden. The proposal is to demolish the existing Rose Lodge and Roseland Resource Centre buildings and replace them with three buildings of 7 to 8 storeys, providing 92 flats, with basement parking, cycle storage, landscaping, refuse storage and new vehicle access from Leigh Close.

Kingston Society does not oppose the redevelopment of brownfield sites in principle. We recognise the need for new homes, and we accept that this part of Kingston Road is already changing. Our concern is more specific: whether a building of this scale, on this stretch of road, is of sufficient architectural quality.

The scheme has been through a long design process, including several stages of review by the Kingston Design Review Panel and Kingston Placemaking Panel. The current proposal is clearly less monolithic than some earlier versions. It has been worked on, refined and justified. But the submitted material still leaves us with a central concern:  the design appears competent rather than convincing, for a development of this size, that is not enough.

The site and the proposal

The site forms part of the former NHS Roselands / Rose Lodge complex on Kingston Road. The applicant describes it as a 0.33 hectare brownfield site in a sustainable location. The existing buildings are not listed, and the site is not within a conservation area. The Planning Statement also notes that Kingston cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply, and that the proposal would contribute 92 homes towards the borough’s housing targets.

Those points carry weighting we do not dispute the principle of residential development on this site. Nor do we argue that the existing buildings must necessarily be retained in their present form. The issue is whether this particular proposal makes a persuasive case for the scale and form of development now being sought.

The scheme would provide a mix of one, two, three and four-bedroom flats, including family-sized homes and wheelchair-accessible units. It would also provide communal amenity space, roof terraces, landscaping and basement parking. These are relevant planning benefits. They do not, however, remove the need for close scrutiny of height, massing, architectural quality, embodied carbon and affordable housing.

Height and the Kingston Road corridor

The proposed buildings exceed 21 metres and therefore fall within Kingston’s definition of a tall building. The applicant’s Tall Building Statement acknowledges that the site is not formally designated as a tall-building opportunity area, but argues that existing and recent larger buildings nearby create an emerging context for this scale of development.

We accept that Kingston Road is not a static place. The adjoining Roseland Clinic redevelopment, Crown House and other recent schemes have already changed the character of this part of the road. More homes may well be appropriate here.

But a changing context still needs good buildings. Indeed, the more Kingston Road intensifies, the more important the quality of each new scheme becomes. A road can become denser and better. It can also become denser and duller.

That is why the height cannot be considered only as a question of precedent. It is also a question of contribution. What will this building give back to Kingston Road? How will it improve the experience of the street? Will it help create a more coherent urban place, or simply add another large block to an already uneven corridor?

What the design review process tells us

The most recent Kingston Placemaking Panel report, from April 2025, was not hostile to the proposal. The Panel commended the refinements made by the new design team and supported the proposed massing and height in townscape terms, subject to further work and evidence.

That support, however, came with important qualifications. The Panel referred to “the incoherence of the elevations” and a “lack of clarity of the architectural identity”. It also called for “a more coherent architectural language” and for refinement of the street-facing elevations to enhance the building’s “civic presence”.

These are not minor matters. They go directly to whether the scheme has reached the quality required for a prominent tall building. The planning authority’s own position, as recorded in the Panel report, was that a tall building may be supported on the site only if there is a clear and convincing argument for the amount of development proposed and for the exceptional quality of the scheme.

This becomes the proper test – the proposal should not be judged only against previous, weaker versions of itself but has to be judged against the scale of its impact on Kingston Road.

Architectural character

The Design and Access Statement seeks to root the proposal in local character. It refers to local brick traditions, horizontal expression, quoining, entrance portals and a disciplined façade grid. These are all reasonable points of reference. The area does contain a mixture of older brick buildings, recent larger developments and more ordinary commercial frontages.

The difficulty is that the submitted images do not yet persuade us that these references have produced a building with real civic quality. The architecture is calmer than before. It is more ordered. It is not crude, and it is not visually chaotic. But the result still feels somewhat dutiful.

This is not an argument for pastiche, nor for decorative excess. Kingston Road does not need theatrical architecture. But it does need buildings with enough depth, care and character to justify their scale.

At present, the street-facing elevations appear too flat in their ambition. The proposal uses a familiar contemporary language of brick panels, repeated bays, inset balconies and contrasting materials. There is nothing inherently wrong with that. The question is whether it has been done well enough here. Our view is that the design has improved, but has not yet crossed the threshold from acceptable to good.

Housing and affordable housing

The proposal would provide 92 new homes, including a significant number of larger flats. The Planning Statement lists 2 four-bedroom flats, 28 three-bedroom flats, 34 two-bedroom flats and 29 one-bedroom flats. It also states that 13% of the homes would be wheelchair accessible, with the remaining units designed as accessible and adaptable dwellings.

Affordable housing remains a concern. The Planning Statement says affordable housing is subject to viability assessment. The applicant’s preferred option appears to include the possibility of selling the residential element to a social housing landlord, subject to viability and grant support, but this is not presented as a firm commitment.

The submitted Financial Viability Assessment records a scheme of 92 units and states that the appraisal shows a deficit for a private sale scheme with a 35% affordable housing provision.

This is a matter for rigorous independent scrutiny. A large, dense scheme on former public-sector land should not pass through the planning system with affordable housing left as an unresolved aspiration. If the public is being asked to accept a substantial increase in height and density, the public benefit must be clear.

Demolition, retrofit and carbon

The applicant has submitted a Retrofit Statement arguing that retention of the existing buildings is not technically viable. It points to the age and construction of the buildings, limited load-bearing capacity, access constraints, poor thermal performance and the difficulty of meeting modern fire, acoustic, energy and accessibility standards. The statement concludes that partial or full retention is not technically viable without significant compromise.

That case may prove persuasive, but it should be tested. Demolition should not be treated as a default setting. The carbon cost of demolition, basement excavation and new construction forms part of the planning balance.

The basement is particularly relevant. The latest Panel recommendations included reducing the basement area to limit carbon-intensive excavation and reducing car parking ratios to encourage active travel.

The current application includes 32 car parking spaces, including disabled bays, together with motorcycle bays and car club provision. The issue for us is not simply the number of spaces. It is whether the basement, the excavation and the associated carbon cost have been justified as part of a genuinely sustainable scheme.

Landscape, courtyard and amenity

The proposal places considerable emphasis on the internal courtyard, roof terraces, planting and shared amenity spaces. These spaces matter. In a development of this density, landscape is not decoration. It is part of how the scheme will function as a place to live.

The design material shows a more developed landscape approach, with planting, play elements and routes through the site. The Panel welcomed positive aspects of the masterplan, including the principle of deck access and duplex apartments. At the same time, it raised concerns about privacy, security, servicing and the practical operation of the courtyard.

Those points need resolution before approval, not afterwards. A courtyard can look generous in a drawing and still work poorly in daily use. Access, overlooking, maintenance, play, planting and security all need to be considered together.

Kingston Society’s view

Kingston Society recognises the need for new homes and accepts the principle of redeveloping this brownfield site. We also recognise that the current scheme has moved on from earlier proposals and that the design team has responded to some of the criticism made through the review process. Our concern is that the architecture has not yet earned the scale of the development.

The Panel’s own language points to the unresolved issue: incoherent elevations, unclear architectural identity and insufficient civic presence. These are not peripheral matters. They are central to whether a tall building is justified in this location.

Kingston Road should not become a corridor where each new large building is defended by pointing to the last one. If this route is to become denser, it must also become better. That means buildings with stronger street presence, more convincing materials, better detailed elevations and a clearer contribution to the public realm.

On the basis of the submitted material, we are not yet convinced that this scheme meets that test. We ask the Council to require a stronger demonstration that the architecture is not merely compliant, but genuinely worthy of its scale and setting.

Share this post

Last Updated on May 22, 2026 by Kingston Society