RIGHT TO REPLY
Bob Phillips comments…

Crafting resilient cities: Balancing AI innovation with the human touch

A KingSoc Soapbox article by Bob Phillips – the views expressed here are not necessarily the views of The Kingston Society.

Tony Lancaster has his say on Balancing AI innovation with the human touch, and gives us lots to think about why and how AI will only succeed if it can embrace some characteristics of intelligent, empathetic human life. At the core of what he is demanding from AI support to design is resilience, which Tony describes as: “the ability not only to construct but to transform spaces that respond to the intricate challenges and beauty of human life”.

Tony is focussing our minds on something crucial to design for successful human living, but, I am not sure I agree 100% with his aim. I would say that resilience is specifically about change and continuity, related to, but not identical to, design. The “intricate challenges and beauty of human life” that Tony refers to are part of something related to resilience, but are not the resilience itself.

Elsewhere in the piece, Tony writes: “At its most profound, urban resilience is about crafting spaces that are emotionally as well as structurally robust, cities that echo the trials, losses, and triumphs of their inhabitants.”That is more like it.

Trials, losses, and triumphs are the experience and consequence of living – in this case, living in the urban streets and spaces. They are not the effects of design; they are the effects of living in the design, or lack of design. Effective design does not create the trials, losses, and triumphs – it creates spaces in which those trials, losses, and triumphs occur. And if it is intelligent the spaces provided are not limiting, but enable or encourage the possibility of creative, effective change.

At the level of a building, rather than a city, this is what Stewart Brand wrote about in How Buildings Learn: What Happens After They’re Built*. This from the man who brought us so much of the vision of the 1960s, including The Whole Earth Catalog:

“Loved buildings are the ones that work well, that suit the people in them, and that show their age and history. All it takes is keeping most everything that works, most everything that is enjoyed, much of what doesn’t get in the way, and helping the rest evolve. That goes better if the place is neither owned nor maintained by remote antagonists, because they distance the building from its users. What makes a building learn is its physical connection to the people within.” page 209

What this says to me is that Tony’s goal, which I share, of “A resilient city is one that retains its character, quirks, and even its scars” is to be achieved by living and evolution, not by design. Good design is obviously vital to this. Good design builds in flexibility and imagination that avoids stifling creative evolution; brilliant design enables or fosters future evolution. But it is the living, not the design itself, that drives the evolution and the creativity that emanates from it.

Tony writes: “True urban architecture does not just organise space; it curates experiences, trials, and triumphs that connect us.” That is true: architecture curates experience – in the sense that it enables it, not that it designs it.

So, Tony’s “quest for understanding machines [that] mirror deeper spiritual pursuits, such as overcoming the ‘illusion of control’ between human and machine” is not, in fact, a quest for AI that will create designs that elevate human life, it is a quest for a design approach, using AI, that enables human life to evolve. That is a subtle, but important difference. In my formulation, when you look for “the accidental discoveries that arise from ‘thinking outside the box’ — or God help me ‘blue sky thinking’”, you are looking for AI to encompass an understanding of how humans change, not asking only for a direct understanding of design just in the here and now.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Last Updated on January 22, 2025 by Kingston Society