The tyranny of modern architecture: why we hate it and how styles like London Vernacular complicate the debate

A KingSoc Soapbox article by Tony Lancaster – the views expressed here are not necessarily the views of The Kingston Society.


]

 

Modern architecture, once a radical response to the industrial age, has engendered widespread disdain for its alienating and dehumanising impact on the built environment. The rejection of ornament, the dominance of rectangular geometries, and the rise of cheque-book architecture have created urban spaces that many experience as monotonous, impersonal, and disconnected from cultural narratives. Architectural critics like Charles Jencks and Rem Koolhaas argue that modernism’s failure lies in its reductionist, top-down approach, which prioritised abstract ideals of functionality and rationality over the emotional and symbolic needs of people. Yet, as new styles like the London Vernacular emerge, the conversation becomes more complex. While the London Vernacular offers a seemingly human-centred response to the excesses of modernism, it may paradoxically risk creating a new form of standardisation, much like Haussmann’s Parisian vision. This essay explores the dual critique of modern architecture while considering whether newer architectural styles, like the London Vernacular, truly offer a meaningful alternative or merely a softened version of modernism’s geometric tyranny.

The failures of modernism: A dehumanising legacy

The core of modernism’s failure lies in its ideological rejection of the past and its insistence on radical new forms. Architects like Le Corbusier envisioned a future of efficiency, order, and clean, rational spaces—principles that would shape 20th-century architecture. Yet, this vision proved deeply flawed in practice.

Pruitt-Igoe housing project, St. Louis, Missouri,

Charles Jencks famously marked “the death of modern architecture” by pointing to the demolition of the Pruitt-Igoe housing project, a symbol of how modernism’s utopian ambitions were thwarted by the reality of soulless, alienating spaces. These buildings, with their stark minimalism and lack of ornament, failed to address the emotional and cultural needs of the communities they housed. Modernism’s relentless pursuit of the machine aesthetic, its rejection of ornamentation as unnecessary, and its preference for rectilinear forms, created environments that felt cold, impersonal, and unwelcoming. If modern architecture died that day we have been been in the hands of Undead Zombie architecture ever since.

Rem Koolhaas, in Junkspace and Delirious New York, critiques modernism’s obsession with order and functionality, arguing that it removed the chaotic vitality of cities and fostered a new kind of architectural excess. The rigid geometries of modernism and the homogenising effects of large-scale developments have eroded the organic, diverse, and unpredictable nature of urban environments.

Rectangular rigidity and the loss of ornamentation

Modernism’s pursuit of rationalism and efficiency is most evident in its geometric rigidity. This relentless focus on straight lines and right angles, as seen in the works of architects like Mies van der Rohe, replaced the flowing, organic forms of earlier architectural movements, such as Baroque or Art Nouveau. These older styles, characterised by their curvilinear forms and ornate details, aimed to evoke emotion and beauty, creating dynamic spaces that engaged with their natural and social environments.

Mies van der Rohe’s Seagram Building New York

The modernist aesthetic, on the other hand, imposed uniform geometries across urban landscapes. Jencks and postmodernists argued that this obsession with geometric purity removed the emotional richness of buildings, turning them into abstracted objects divorced from human experience. Ornamentation—long seen as a means to communicate cultural identity, historical continuity, and beauty—was cast aside as mere decoration. The result was a built environment that felt soulless, unable to foster a sense of place or identity.

Postmodernists like Robert Venturi countered this trend by reintroducing complexity, contradiction, and ornamentation into architecture, arguing that ornamentation serves not only aesthetic ends but also creates emotional connections between people and their environment.

The rise of cheque-book architecture and the loss of cohesion

Another crucial aspect of modern architecture’s failure is its commodification through “cheque-book architecture.” This phenomenon, exemplified by the rise of “starchitects” designing iconic, high-profile buildings for the highest bidder, prioritises aesthetic novelty or corporate branding over public engagement or contextual sensitivity. Koolhaas critiques this excess, describing how the globalised, capitalist model of architecture has led to spaces that, while visually impressive, are hollow in meaning and disconnected from local contexts.

Charles Jencks also criticises the proliferation of architectural icons that serve as symbols of financial power rather than places of cultural or communal significance. This shift towards monumental but disconnected architecture has compounded the alienation felt in modernist urban environments.

The London Vernacular: mitigating modernism or a new form of monotony?

Amidst the critique of modernism, the emergence of the London Vernacular style offers a potential antidote to its alienating effects. This style embraces traditional materials such as brick, restrained ornamentation, and human-scaled proportions, aiming to reconnect buildings with local context. The London Vernacular’s reliance on familiar, tactile materials and references to London’s historical housing stock creates an inviting atmosphere, mitigating some of the sterility associated with modernist designs.

New London Vernacular Indigo Square Surbiton

While it mitigates modernism’s cold rationality through texture and materiality, the London Vernacular remains tethered to rectilinear forms, suggesting it may not entirely escape modernism’s influence. The repetition of similar design elements across projects risks creating a new kind of monotony, rather than a genuine revival of architectural diversity.

The challenge of escaping modernism’s legacy

The criticism of modern architecture is complex, extending beyond aesthetic preferences to concerns about the role architecture plays in shaping human experience. Modernism’s rejection of ornament, its geometric purity, and its embrace of abstract rationalism have left a legacy of alienation and disconnection. Critics like Jencks and Koolhaas argue that modernism failed to engage with the emotional, cultural, and symbolic needs of people.

The rise of the London Vernacular offers a response, reintroducing local narratives and familiar materials into urban development. However, it also raises questions about whether it truly offers a meaningful alternative to modernism or merely softens its edges.


Bibliography:

  • Jencks, Charles. The Language of Post-Modern Architecture. Academy Editions, 1977. (A foundational work that explores the shift from modernist to postmodernist architectural thinking.
  • Koolhaas, Rem. Delirious New York: A Retroactive Manifesto for Manhattan. The Monacelli Press, 1978. (Manhattan as a symbol of modern urban intensity—its density, radical pragmatism, and unpredictable creativity are seen as organic, even inevitable products of urban life pushed to extremes)
  • Venturi, Robert. Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture. Museum of Modern Art, 1966. (For Venturi, rejecting the Modernists he believes architecture should reflect the messiness of life, embracing ambiguity, irony, and layered meanings rather than strict functionalism and simplicity.
  • Sudjic, Deyan. The Edifice Complex: How the Rich and Powerful Shape the World. Penguin Books, 2006. (For those interested in how personal legacies shape our built environment, the book’s a fascinating reflection on architecture as a symbol of power and human ambition.)
  • Le Corbusier. Towards a New Architecture. Dover Publications, 1985. (A radical manifesto that champions function, simplicity, and the “machine aesthetic,” urging architecture to break from tradition and embrace industrial materials and modern efficiency.)

Architecture concepts:

Modernism: Rooted in the early 20th century, modernism sought to break with historical styles, advocating for minimalism, functionalism, and a rejection of ornamentation. Architects like Le Corbusier promoted a machine aesthetic, viewing buildings as tools for living, defined by clean lines and rational geometry.

Postmodernism: Emerging as a reaction to modernism’s stark minimalism, postmodernism reintroduced ornamentation, symbolism, and a sense of playfulness. Figures like Charles Jencks and Robert Venturi argued for “messy vitality” and complex, layered architecture that embraced historical references and contradictions.

International Style: A branch of modernism popularised by architects like Mies van der Rohe and Philip Johnson, the International Style focused on volume over mass, balance over symmetry, and the rejection of decoration. Its hallmark is the use of glass, steel, and concrete, creating open, flowing spaces.

Brutalism: A subset of modernism, Brutalism emphasised raw concrete and functional form. Its often imposing and monumental structures, such as social housing projects, became symbols of government intervention but were later criticised for their dehumanising effects.

London Vernacular: A contemporary architectural style in London, it uses traditional materials like brick, often with restrained ornamentation and human-scale proportions. The style seeks to reconnect modern developments with the city’s historical housing patterns while balancing modern needs with a sense of local identity.

Cheque-book architecture: A critical term used to describe the rise of celebrity architects (starchitects) who are commissioned to create iconic, high-profile buildings, often prioritising aesthetics or corporate branding over community engagement or contextual relevance.

Share this post

Last Updated on October 27, 2026 by Kingston Society